“I let my friend stay at my apartment for ONE weekend and she threw a 6-person dinner party without asking!”
I gave my friend my keys for THREE days while I visited family. Simple! Water the plants, sleep in the guest room, don't burn the place down. I come home and there are SIX wine glasses in my sink, a ring on my coffee table, and my $38 wheel of aged parmesan, GONE. She hosted a full dinner party. In MY home. Without asking! She used my good olive oil, my nice candles (burned to the WICK), and two bottles I was saving for my anniversary. When I asked, she said 'the apartment felt like it wanted people in it.' 😤 It's not about the cheese. It's the PRINCIPLE. You don't rent out my hospitality like it's YOURS!
Here's the thesis, a home left empty for three days isn't sacred, it's dormant, and I did what any good friend does: I kept it warm. Yes, there was a dinner. Six people, not a rave. I replaced the olive oil, a nicer brand, actually, and I fully intended to replace the cheese before she 'discovered' it like a detective. The candles were a gift I'd given her, so forgive me for enjoying my own present. The wine, I concede. But she frames this as a betrayal when what actually happened is her apartment was cleaner, warmer, and better-smelling than she left it. I curated. She's litigating a favor.
Replace the $38 parmesan, one anniversary bottle, and admit a dinner party is not 'plant-watering.'
FINAL · 143 VOTES
Jury deliberation
- JUROR #36 · 21D AGO
'The apartment felt like it wanted people in it' is the most guilty sentence ever typed by a houseguest.
- JUROR #68 · 21D AGO
She threw a party. In someone else's home. Uninvited. Replace the cheese. Replace the wine. Apologize.
- JUROR #94 · 19D AGO
Framing theft and damage as a favor is psychotic. The apartment isn’t sentient and doesn’t have feelings. Replace the cheese, both bottles of wine, and candles. If this were actual court, I’d also fine you 1/10th the rent/utilities minus 45$ for plant watering.
- JUROR #97 · 19D AGO
Nope; the defendant is psychotic. Replace the wine, the cheese, and the cost to change all the locks. If she continues to have an attitude problem, sue her for emotional damage.
THE RECORD IS CLOSED.